ICICI Direct Vs 5paisa.com step-by-step comparison between all aspect of share brokers like Active clients, Trading platform, Brokerage charges, Customer care supports & tools, Margin/leverage, Account opening charges etc.
ICICI Direct Vs 5paisa.com Side-by-side Comparison
| Broker Name | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Broker Info | ICICI Direct Review | 5paisa Review |
ICICI Direct Vs 5paisa.com Background Comparison
| Background | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Incorporation Year | 2000 | 2005 |
| Broker Services | Full-Service Discount Broker | Full-Service Discount Broker |
| Website URL | www.icicidirect.com | www.5paisa.com |
| Contact Number | 1860 123 1122 | +91 8976689766 |
| Exchanges Accessible | NSE, BSE | NSE, BSE, MCX-SX |
| Demat (NSDL/CDSL) | NSDL & CDSL | CDSL |
| Active Total Client | 10,00,000+ Clients | 1,00,000+ Clients |
Introduction
| Introduction | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Broker Reviews /Opinion | ICICI Direct is a subsidary of ICICI bank. ICICIDirect is india’s one of the top 5 full service stock broker. Offers all services at one palce like Trading account+ Bank account+ Demat Account | Overall, thanks to 5paisa for its low brokerage costs and good services, 5paisa.com value for traders across the full spectrum of the trader’s community. What impresses us most about 5paisa.com is its drive to continue efforts and offer the best possible customer experience. 5paisa is a discount stock broker and it is useful for the intraday trader. |
Broker Ratings and Reviews Comparison
| Broker Rating/Reviews | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Opening Charges | ★★★★ | ★★★★ |
| Commissions & Fees | ★★★★ | ★★★★ |
| Trading Platforms & Tools | ★★★★ | ★★★★ |
| Order Execution | ★★★★ | ★★★★ |
| Fund Add/Withdraw | ★★★★ | ★★★★ |
| Customer Services | ★★★★ | ★★★★ |
| Overall Rating | ★★★★ | ★★★★ |
Usable for Investors Category Comparison
| Useful for Type of Investors | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Day Traders | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Active Investor/Trader | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Investor | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
Account Opening Fees and AMC Comparison
| Account Opening Fees and AMC | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Trading Account Opening Charges | ₹ 975 | Rs. 650 |
| Trading Annual Maintenance Charges | ₹ 0 | Free |
| Demat Account Opening Fees | ₹ 0 | Free |
| Demat Annual Maintenance Charges | ₹ 700 | Free 1st Year (Rs.400/Per Annum) |
| Commodity Fees | NA | Rs.0 |
| Offer DP Service | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
Available Trading Brokerage Plans Comparison
| Account Opening Fees and AMC | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Trading Account Opening Charges | ₹ 975 | Rs. 650 |
| Trading Annual Maintenance Charges | ₹ 0 | Free |
| Demat Account Opening Fees | ₹ 0 | Free |
| Demat Annual Maintenance Charges | ₹ 700 | Free 1st Year (Rs.400/Per Annum) |
| Commodity Fees | NA | Rs.0 |
| Offer DP Service | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
Trading Brokerage Charges Comparison
| Brokerage Charges | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Plan Subscription Summery | Percentage Based Brokerage Charges | 5paisa charges only flat fee of Rs.10 per order for all segments including Equity, Equity Derivatives (F&O) and Currency. |
| Equity Intraday Charges | Equity Intraday 0.05% | Rs.10 per executed order. |
| Equity Delivery Charges | Delivery 0.25%- Negotiable | Rs.10 per executed order. |
| Equity Futures Charges | One side for Intraday & 0.05% on Turnover overnight | Rs.10 per executed order. |
| Equity Options Charges | Intraday ₹ 25 Per lot for Intraday & Overnight ₹ 95 per lot | Rs.10 per executed order. |
| Currency Futures Charges | One side for Intraday & 0.05% on Turnover overnight | Rs.10 per executed order. |
| Currency Options Charges | Intraday ₹ 25 Per lot for Intraday & Overnight ₹ 95 per lot | Rs.10 per executed order. |
| Commodity Charges | NA | NA |
| Minimum Brokerage Fees | 0.05% OR 5 Paisa on 100 rupees | Flat Chrages Rs.10 |
| Any Hidden Cost | No, ✖ | No, ✖ |
| Call & Trade Charges | First 20 Calls Free Than ₹ 25 per call & trade | Rs.100 /per call(No order limit). |
Wait! Looking for Best Demat Account
FREE Investing in Stocks & Mutual Funds with No 1 broker in India!!
+1 Crore Happy Customers
Zero Brokerage on Equity Delivery Trades
Flat ₹20 or 0.03% (whichever is lower) for Intraday and F&O
Trade with the best platforms and tools
Available Margins / Leverage Comparison
| Margins or Leverage | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Equity Margin Intraday | Upto 16x times for equity cash. | Upto 3 to 12 times for equity cash. |
| Equity Margin Delivery | Upto 8x times for equity delivery | Upto 3.5 times for equity delivery. |
| Equity Margin Futures | Upto 8x times for equity futures | Upto 2 times for futures. |
| Equity Margin Options | Upto 5x times for equity options | Upto 2 times for option short selling and No margin for option buyers. |
| Currency Margin Futures | Upto 8x for currency futures | Upto 2 Times for Intraday. |
| Currency Margin Options | Upto 8x for currency options | Upto 2 Times for Intraday. |
| Commodity Margin | NA | NA |
Transparency and Transaction and other Government charges, Tax e s Comparison
| Transparency & Other Fees | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Equity Day Trading | 0.00325% or Rs.325/per crore. | 0.00325% or Rs.325/per crore. |
| Equity Delivery | 0.00325% or Rs.325/per crore. | 0.00325% or Rs.325/per crore. |
| Equity Futures Trading | 0.0019% or Rs.190/per crore. | 0.0019% or Rs.190/per crore. |
| Equity Options Trading | 0.05% or Rs.5000/per crore. | 0.05% or Rs.5000/per crore. |
| Currency Futures Trading | 0.0011% or Rs.110/per crore. | 0.0011% or Rs.110/per crore. |
| Currency Options Trading | 0.04% or Rs.4000/per crore. | 0.04% or Rs.4000/per crore. |
| Commodities Trading | NA | NA |
| AMC Charge | ₹ 700/- (1st year Free). | Rs.400/- (1st year Free). |
| DP Transaction Fees | ₹ 25/per transaction. | Rs.25/per transaction. |
| Offline order placing Charge | ₹ 25 /per call. | Rs.100 /per call(No order limit). |
| Sebi Charges | Rs.15/per cr. | Rs.15/per cr. |
| GST | 18% on Brokerage + Transaction charges. | 18% on Brokerage + Transaction charges. |
| Stamp Duty | As per Clients state. | As per Clients state. |
Available Trading Platform / Software Comparison
| Trading Platforms / Software | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Desktop Trading Platform | Trade Racer | 5PaisaTradeStation |
| Web Based | secure.icicidirect.com | www.5paisa.com << Trade |
| Mobile Application | ICICI Direct Mobile | 5Paisa – Online Share Market Trading App |
Trading Platform Details Comparison
| Trading Platform Details | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Demo (Desktop) Platform | Demo Link | Demo Link |
| Windows Desktop platform | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| MAC Desktop platform | No, ✖ | No, ✖ |
| Web Trading URL | secure.icicidirect.com | www.5paisa.com/ |
| Web Trading Portals Info | Yes, Available ✔ | 5paisa Web Info link |
| Mobile Site | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Mobile Trading Availability | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Mobile Trading Application | Download Link | Download Link |
| Mobile App Demo | Demo Link | Demo Link |
| Android / Ios Mobile App | Yes, ✔ Both Available | Yes, ✔ Both Available |
Charting Facility Comparison
| Charting | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Intraday (Day Chart) | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| End of Day (Daily Chart) | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Coding/Backtesting | No, ✖ | No, ✖ |
Reporting Comparison
| Reporting | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Trade Online Reports | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| PNL Online Reports | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Online Contract Notes | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
Trading Support and Tools Comparison
| Support & Tools | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Research & Tips | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Brokerage Calculator | No, ✖ | No, ✖ |
| Span Margin Calculator | No, ✖ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Trailing Stoploss | No, ✖ | No, ✖ |
| Training & Education | Yes, ✔ Blogs, Articles | Yes, ✔ Blogs, Articles |
Trading Features Comparison
| Useful Trading Features | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| 3 in 1 Account (Bank+Trading+Demat) | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Instant Fund withdrawal | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Relationship Managers (RM) | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Charts | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Algo Trading / Robot | No, ✖ | No, ✖ |
| Mobile SMS Alerts | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Online Demo | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Online Portfolio | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Margin for Future Trading | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Combined Records for Equity & Commodity | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Intraday Sq.off Timing | 3.15 PM | 3.10 PM |
| Can NRI Trade | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Extra Features | Ask to Broker | Ask to Broker |
Services and Available Option Category Comparison
| Investment Service and Available Options | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Equity Cash & Future & Option | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Currency Derivatives (Forex) | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Commodity | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Online IPO Request | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Mutual Funds (MF) | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Bonds / Negotiable Certificate of Deposit | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Banking Services | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Direct Insurance | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Forex Investment | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| MF SIP Investments | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| PMS Services | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Other Options | Ask to Broker | Ask to Broker |
Fund ADD / Fund Withdrawal Procedure Comparison
| Fund Add/Withdrawal Process | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Fund Pay In and Pay out | Add Fund: Cheque, Online Bank TraNsfer using IMPS, NEFT or RTGS, UPI, Net-Banking and payment gatway. Withdrawal fund: Bank Tranfer | Add Fund: Cheque, Online Bank TraNsfer using IMPS, NEFT or RTGS, UPI, Net-Banking and payment gatway. Withdrawal fund: Bank Tranfer |
| Time for Payout | 24 hours (working days) | 24 hours (working days) |
| Linked Bank | You can linked ICICI Bank account | Near about 23 bank available for fund credit and Rs.9 for per transaction. |
Trading Order Types Comparison
| Trading Order Types | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Cash N Carry (CNC Order) | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Margin Intraday Square (MIS Order) | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Normal (NRML Order) | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Cover Order | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Bracket Order | No, ✖ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Buy Today Sell Tomorrow (BTST) | No Information | No Information |
| Sell Today Buy Tomorrow (STBT) | No Information | No Information |
| AMO -After Market Order | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| GTG-Good Till Cancelled | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
Customer Care Services and Numbers Comparison
| Customer Care Services | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Customer Care Service 24/7 | No, ✖ | No, ✖ |
| Email Support | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Live Chat Online | No, ✖ | No, ✖ |
| Phone Support | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Toll-Free Number | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Support by Branch | Yes, Available ✔ | No, ✖ |
| Customer Care Contact Number | 1860 123 1122 | 8976689766 |
| Account Opening Procedure | Paperless | Paperless |
| Customer Support Email | [email protected] | [email protected] |
| Complaints Support Email | [email protected] | [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] |
| Educational Blog | Financial Services Blog | www.5paisa.com |
| Head Office Address | ICICI Centre, H.T. Parekh Marg, Churchgate, Mumbai – 400020 | Sun Infotech Park, Road No. 16V, Plot No.B-23 Thane, Industrial Area, Wagle Estate,,Thane – 400604 |
Investment Advice/Tips/ Research & Reports Comparison
| Investment Advice -Tips, Research & Reports | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Equity Research | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Mutual Fund Research | Yes, Available ✔ | No Info |
| ETF Research | No, ✖ | No, ✖ |
| Daily Report | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Free Tips- Advisory | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| Company Result Analysis | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
| News & Alerts | Yes, Available ✔ | Yes, Available ✔ |
ICICI Direct Vs 5paisa.com Advantages & Disadvantages Comparison Comparison
| Advantages & Disadvantages | ICICI Direct | 5paisa.com |
| Pros / Likes | 1) 3-IN-1 Account Available 2) Excellent Customer Care Support 3) Branches in your city. 4) Fast & Secure Trading Platform 5) Experience in stock broking | 1) Educational articles are Excellent. 2) Customer service is very good. 3) All three trading platforms are fantastic. 4) Offers very Low Brokerage only flat fee of Rs.10 per executed order. 5) Mobile App crosses 1 Million downloads. |
| Cons / Dislikes | 1) High Brokerage Charges 2) MCX and NCDEX commodity trading is unavailable. 3) Higher charges of Rs.25 per transaction for Demat. 4) Rs.25 Extra for call n trade. | 1) Call & Trade is Rs.100 for per call which is higher as compare to other brokers. 2) MCX and NCDEX commodity trading is unavailable. 3) Higher charges of Rs.25 per transaction for Demat. 4) No Branches in your city. |
| Promotion or offer | 1st Year Free Demat Annual Maintenance Charges (AMC) | 1st Year Free Demat Annual Maintenance Charges (AMC). 5paisa offers Low Trade brokerage just Rs.10 per order + Demat AMC free for 1st year + Free Mutual Fund Account. |
More Stock Broker Compare
